Burial · Egypt · 3 min read, approximately

Umm el-Qaab: dating the royal tombs of Abydos

A radiocarbon study of the royal cemetery at Abydos found that its dates agree with the archaeological order of the tombs but come out 100-150 years earlier than the historical chronology established until then. What that says about dating the First Dynasty, and what it does not.

The explanations distinguish finds, interpretations and open questions. Sources appear at the end of the page.

The site

According to the abstract of the article by Görsdorf, Dreyer and Hartung in the journal Radiocarbon, since 1977 the German Institute of Archaeology in Cairo has been reexamining the archaic royal necropolis of Umm el-Qaab at Abydos, about 500 km south of Cairo. The necropolis has three parts: in the south, the tomb complexes of six kings and one queen of Dynasty 1 and of two kings of Dynasty 2; in the middle, a cemetery with royal tombs of Dynasty 0 and early Dynasty 1; in the north, the predynastic cemetery. The tombs are partly destroyed and deprived of most of their contents, but according to the authors they and the remaining artefacts are "a major source for the early dynastic period". Source 1.

What was dated, and how

Sixteen new samples were taken mainly from remains of wooden roofs and coffins, and in the earliest tombs from mattings. According to the abstract, the results "in general are in good accordance with the relative archaeological dating of the tombs, but 100-150 yr earlier than the so far established historical chronology". Source 1.

Two clocks out of step

Relative dating establishes an order: which tomb came before which. A historical chronology attaches years to that order. According to the abstract, the radiocarbon dates confirm the order but move the years back. The abstract gives neither the calibrated dates themselves nor the historical chronology it compares them with, so one cannot derive from it by how many years, for example, the Met's boundary of 3100 BCE would move. The site keeps that boundary for navigation and notes the discrepancy beside it, without computing a new date. Sources 1, 3.

Royal burial before the First Dynasty

The same abstract mentions royal tombs "from Dynasty 0" in the middle part of the cemetery. According to Engel's paper on the royal tombs, royal burial is attested at the site at least from the time of Sekhen/Ka of Dynasty 0. The Met's timeline does not use the term "Dynasty 0"; it states that in Naqada III (about 3300-3100 BCE) "it is now known that Abydos was the burial ground of late Predynastic leaders". The article is placed in the Early Dynastic period because its dated subject is the royal tombs of Dynasties 1 and 2; the earlier part of the cemetery begins in the Predynastic period. Sources 1, 2, 3.

Scope of reading: the page of the Radiocarbon article by Görsdorf, Dreyer and Hartung was read on 24 October 2026, with its abstract only; the full text and the dates of individual samples were not read. The PDF of Engel's paper could not be opened (the repository's security check blocked access), and the sentence attributed to it comes from an earlier reading made for this site and could not be checked again. Excavation reports were not read.

Source

Sources and further reading

The research and references behind this page. Rights to external content remain with their owners.

  1. 1 New 14C Dating of the Archaic Royal Necropolis Umm El-Qaab at Abydos (Egypt)

    Jochen Görsdorf, Günter Dreyer, Ulrich Hartung · 1997 · Checked

  2. 2 The Royal Tombs [Umm el-Qaab] (Engel; PDF in the Propylaeum-DOK repository, Heidelberg University Library)

    Engel · Not opened for checking

  3. 3 Egypt, 8000-2000 B.C. (Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, chronology)

    The Metropolitan Museum of Art · 2000 · Checked

Continue from here

Follow the next connection

Every card comes from a documented relation or an editorial link. The reason line explains the connection.

The UNESCO World Heritage Centre describes the necropolis of Memphis as evidence of the development of the royal tomb from the "mastaba" to the pyramid. Which stages the source dates, and which it leaves undated.

3 min read, approximately

Related reading.

The Met's timeline presents Hierakonpolis, "far to the south", as the largest population center known in Naqada I (about 3800-3650 BCE). Three statements from the same source, and a question it leaves open: why the south.

3 min read, approximately

Related reading.

Reading, accessibility & privacy tools

Adjust the reading experience to suit you. These tools complement your browser and device accessibility settings. Changes apply to this page; they are kept for another visit only if you allowed that in the privacy dialog.